New Urban Institute research examines the challenges homeowners face rebuilding after disasters & what it takes to close the financing gaps.
More than a year after the May 2025 EF3 tornado devastated parts of St. Louis, recovery continues to raise difficult questions about housing, financial resources, and the long-term stability of affected neighborhoods.
A new report from the Urban Institute, Closing Capital Gaps for Single-Family Households: Financing for More Equitable Disaster Recovery, takes a closer look at these challenges. Published in November 2026, the research examines disaster recovery financing across seven major events between 2017 and 2025, including the St. Louis tornadoes.
Drawing on research and interviews with 17 practitioners from local government, nonprofits, philanthropy, and community development financial institutions (CDFIs), the report explores why some households recover more quickly than others and what can be done to make recovery resources more accessible.
Several findings from St. Louis are particularly relevant as our region continues to navigate the long-term effects of the tornado.
THE INSURANCE GAP: HOMEOWNERS WITHOUT COVERAGE FACE GREATER RISK
Homeowners insurance is one of the first lines of financial protection after a disaster, but not every household has coverage.
The report highlights a concern raised by a St. Louis interviewee: older homeowners living on fixed incomes may drop their homeowners insurance once their mortgages are paid off. Without a mortgage payment requiring insurance coverage, some homeowners may choose to eliminate the expense, leaving themselves financially exposed.
For households already living on limited incomes, the cost of maintaining insurance can compete with other basic expenses. When disaster strikes, the consequences can be devastating.
The report also emphasizes that having insurance does not necessarily mean having enough coverage. Rising construction costs, labor shortages, and increased demand for building materials after disasters can leave homeowners with insurance payouts that fall short of actual repair and rebuilding expenses.
THE WAIT FOR FEDERAL RECOVERY FUNDING
One of the report's most significant findings concerns the timing of federal disaster recovery assistance.
Community Development Block Grant Disaster Recovery (CDBG-DR) funding can provide substantial assistance for housing repairs, rehabilitation, and reconstruction following federally declared disasters. However, the funding has historically been slow to reach affected communities. According to research cited in the report, CDBG-DR funding takes an average of 20 months after a disaster to arrive in communities.
As of the report's November 2026 publication, neither the January 2025 Los Angeles wildfires nor the May 2025 St. Louis tornadoes had received CDBG-DR appropriations, despite more than a year having passed since both disasters.
Even after funding is appropriated, communities must have a program in place to determine how it will be distributed, establish local resources, and navigate federal requirements. This creates a difficult gap between when families need assistance and when public funding becomes available. Homeowners cannot always wait months or years to begin repairs, particularly when damaged roofs, structural problems, and other unresolved issues can lead to further deterioration.
The report also notes that communities attempting to use other funding sources while waiting for CDBG-DR reimbursement face additional challenges, including federal requirements related to documenting disaster damage, environmental reviews, labor standards, and avoiding duplication of benefits.
PHILANTHROPY AND THE NEED FOR LOCAL LEADERSHIP
Disaster recovery requires more than federal assistance. Philanthropic organizations, foundations, financial institutions, nonprofits, and local governments all have a role in helping households recover.
The report includes a particularly notable observation from a St. Louis interviewee, who believed the city's hesitancy to act decisively following the 2025 tornadoes weakened engagement from the philanthropic sector. This raises an important question about the relationship between public leadership and private investment.
Philanthropic organizations can help fill immediate funding gaps, support nonprofit recovery efforts, provide flexible resources, and help households access assistance that traditional government programs may not cover. However, the report explains that philanthropic participation varies significantly from one disaster to another and may decline after the immediate relief period.
Clear priorities, coordinated leadership, and an established recovery strategy can help create an environment where philanthropic and private partners understand where their resources are needed and how they can contribute.
WHY LOW-INTEREST LOANS AREN'T ALWAYS THE ANSWER
The report also examines the limitations of relying on loans to finance disaster recovery.
Small Business Administration (SBA) disaster loans can provide substantial assistance for home repairs, but they are loans that must be repaid, not grants.
Interviewees in both Detroit and St. Louis explained that even low-interest loans can be financially out of reach for lower-income and fixed-income households. Homeowners already managing debt, reduced income, or unexpected expenses may be unable or unwilling to take on another monthly payment.
The report further explains that SBA loan eligibility relies on credit scores and repayment capacity, which can exclude some of the households with the greatest recovery needs.
Following Hurricane Harvey, lower-income homeowners were 58 percent less likely to be approved for SBA loans and received 54 percent less in loan dollars per dollar of damage than higher-income homeowners.
The findings underscore the importance of offering multiple forms of assistance, including grants, forgivable loans, deferred-payment options, and financing designed around a household's actual ability to repay.
A loan may be a useful recovery tool for one household but an additional financial burden for another.
BRIDGE FINANCING COULD HELP CONTRACTORS GET TO WORK SOONER
One of the most practical St. Louis-specific observations in the report involves the contractors performing tornado recovery work. A local interviewee suggested that contractors could have benefited from bridge loans backed by award letters documenting committed public funding. This type of financing could have allowed contractors to begin housing recovery work while waiting for formal government contracts and payments.
The report points to examples from other disasters where revolving loan funds and bridge financing helped homeowners and contractors move forward while waiting for federal recovery dollars.
For example, Strongward's Recovery Acceleration Fund, operated by the CDFI Credit Human following Hurricane Ida, provided financing for home repairs that could later be reimbursed through CDBG-DR funding.
Similar approaches could help address the delays that often leave homeowners waiting for repairs and contractors waiting for the resources to begin work.
For St. Louis, this raises an opportunity to consider how local financial institutions, CDFIs, philanthropy, and public agencies might work together to establish financing mechanisms that keep recovery projects moving.
REBUILDING SHOULD ALSO MEAN BUILDING BACK STRONGER
Beyond repairing damaged homes, the report emphasizes the importance of investing in housing resilience.
Storm protection, stronger roofing systems, improved drainage, and other upgrades can help reduce future damage. However, these improvements often come with additional costs that lower-income homeowners cannot afford. The report notes that an additional 20 percent could be added to SBA loan limits following the 2025 St. Louis tornadoes for eligible storm-protection upgrades.
But there is another challenge: many federal recovery grants focus on bringing homes back to a habitable condition. Additional structural repairs may be necessary before homeowners can even consider weatherization or other resilience improvements. The question becomes how to finance stronger, safer homes without placing additional financial burdens on the households least able to afford them.
Recovery programs that incorporate resilience funding from the beginning could help address this challenge rather than treating protection against future disasters as an optional expense.
ANOTHER PERSPECTIVE: WHAT EARLIER RESEARCH TELLS US ABOUT NEIGHBORHOOD RECOVERY
A separate August 2025 analysis from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, Home Values after a Tornado: What Can St. Louis Learn from Little Rock in 2023?, offers another important perspective on the long-term effects of tornado damage. The analysis draws on research by Jeffrey P. Cohen and Violeta Gutkowski examining the March 2023 Little Rock tornado and its effects on nearby property values.
The research found that even undamaged homes experienced declining sale prices when located near tornado-damaged properties. In Little Rock, undamaged homes within 250 meters of a damaged property experienced an estimated 36% short-term decline in sales prices. The effects diminished with distance and were no longer evident after nine months.
While the study did not find a greater overall decline in property values in lower-income neighborhoods, it did find that homeowners in wealthier neighborhoods were able to begin repairs sooner. This raises concerns about prolonged displacement for lower-income households that lack the savings or resources to repair their homes quickly.
The Federal Reserve's analysis also cautioned that St. Louis could face a longer recovery given the substantially greater estimated damage from the 2025 tornado. The analysis estimated $1.6 billion in damages in St. Louis city alone, compared with approximately $500 million in Little Rock.
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR ST. LOUIS
The Urban Institute's research makes clear that disaster recovery is not simply a matter of securing funding. It is also about how quickly resources reach households, whether assistance is structured in ways people can afford, and whether the organizations responsible for recovery have the capacity to coordinate and deliver support.
For St. Louis, the findings point to several important considerations:
Improve coordination: Establish clear leadership and priorities that help align public resources, philanthropy, financial institutions, and nonprofit recovery partners.
Expand access to flexible financing: Develop funding options that recognize that not every household can take on additional debt.
Address timing gaps: Explore bridge financing that allows contractors and homeowners to move forward while waiting for government funding.
Strengthen recovery navigation: Ensure homeowners have access to trusted assistance with insurance claims, applications, documentation, contractors, and rebuilding.
Invest in resilience: Incorporate storm protection and stronger construction standards into recovery programs while ensuring upgrades remain affordable.
The report offers examples from communities across the country that have developed creative approaches to these challenges. While each disaster and local recovery environment is different, the lessons provide a useful starting point for thinking about how St. Louis can strengthen its own recovery efforts. Ultimately, rebuilding after a disaster should mean more than returning homes to their previous condition. It should mean helping families remain in their communities, protecting homeownership, and ensuring neighborhoods are better prepared for what comes next.
Closing Capital Gaps for Single-Family Households: Financing for More Equitable Disaster Recovery
Rebecca Marx, Andrew Rumbach, and Grace Koch
Urban Institute | November 2026